Column

Why big business should stop lecturing schools on motivation and start listening

Photo of Andre Perry

Degree of  Interest

Employees of Algiers Charter at the Kickoff 15 pep rally.

Employees of Algiers Charter at the Kickoff 15 pep rally.

Public school systems are so busy trying to emulate the business world they forget that educators can teach other sectors how to motivate employees. Schools are more like rap groups and teams than banks, and the art of motivating school employees should reflect that reality.

Last week, I served as a judge for the Algiers Charter’s Kickoff 2015, a pep rally/competition for faculty and staff of the charter network to celebrate the new academic year. Personnel of each school competed for the Swag Flag for the best cheer, determined by judges. The contest was followed by a motivational speech, and Adrian Morgan, CEO, presented the charter network’s goals and strategies for the upcoming year.

I would love CEOs in the private sector to have seen Algiers Charter motivate their employees. Typically it’s the opposite. Several schools lean on TED Talks and Steve Jobs-like rallies to make big announcements or kickoffs.

Related: The graduation rates from every school district in one map

Reform’s current focus on standards-based curricula and choice certainly motivate growth in a way that Adam Smith, forefather of the political economy, could appreciate. Philosophers like Kenneth Strike have noted that, in this perspective, students are viewed instrumentally as consumers and future workers.

In this frame, schools are built to push individual success, productivity and competitiveness. Schools improve with infusions of human capital, which leads to the consequential removal of people who could not meet assigned targets.

From this perspective, schools look more like corporations and/or banks, in which bottom lines are met, individual advancement is “merited” and success is brought to scale.

Related: There’s one education reform proven to work on a national scale, so why aren’t we trying it?

Algiers Charter CEO Adrian Morgan rapping at the Kickoff 15 pep rally.

Algiers Charter CEO Adrian Morgan rapping at the Kickoff 15 pep rally.

Schools, like teams, are working toward common goals and those goals go beyond the school itself. Students as well as families, teachers and communities need schools to prepare people for college and careers. They must also develop citizens. Everyone has a role to play, but many can’t be fired or replaced. We are all members of the team. Leaders have to motivate and focus a large number of people. This is why schools need pep rallies that resonate with the home team. Take the rap lyrics performed to the song Teach Me How to Dougie by Algiers Charter’s CEO Adrian Morgan:

Teach Them How To Study (song to Teach Me How to Dougie)

Original Lyrics – Adrian Morgan, Algiers Charter CEO

“August 2015

Hey Algiers Charter (what?)

You can teach them how to study

You know why?

Cause we ain’t got no dummies

All I see is teachers with commitment

Students love to learn with teachers who don’t relent

Get your standards out, study ‘em every night

Thanks to you LEAP and PARCC will be all right

In the classroom, rockin’ 4 – Core

So students can be learnin’ more and more and more and more

Done with GEE now, it’s EOC time

Graduation rates climbing higher up all the time

SSC too I didn’t forget you

Coachin’ and operatin’ is whatcha you gotta do

Pay them bills too, so learning can be blended

Manage that culture through, so student fights be mended

When it’s all done, it’s graduation

Students now citizens will rule this nation.”

Motivation is about validating a community while compelling it to improve. The goal of school reform isn’t to simply increase test scores; it’s to improve communities. To what end is reform, if community values are debased? We shouldn’t try to reform schools in spite of community. Consequently, more CEOs should be rapping. The goals of an organization can be taught in ways that uplift starting from the foundations of where folk come from. For too long, making a scholar meant imitating a white man from New England with thick rims, a grey beard and elbow patches. We should motivate people by accepting where they are from and what they bring to market of ideas.

By no means is Morgan a rapper (I’m extremely happy he chose to be an educator), but I would love to see Jack Welch, former CEO of General Electric and business icon, motivate a school. He would have to rap the values of a school’s community.

Morgan also presented the organization’s goals using a standard-issue PowerPoint. But other exuberant performances proved that strategic planning, motivation and reorganization can feel like home. If we want community members to teach, lead and service their own organizations, we must honor them.

Related: Why there’s no such thing as the first day of school in New Orleans

Algiers Charter has always been a community effort. Before the national stalwarts of the charter school movement settled in a drain New Orleans, a group of city residents who resided on the West Bank of the Mississippi River – Algiers – formed a nonprofit that would eventually be the first organization to open schools. The Algiers community was largely spared from the flooding that inundated most of the East Bank. While the New Orleans Public School Board was terminating 7,500 employees, Algiers Charter (the nickname of Algiers Charter School Association*) selected principals who were also choosy in whom they hired. One of those hires, Rene Lewis Carter, would become Louisiana Middle School Principal of the year. She trained under another decorated leader in the network, Mary Laurie, who is featured in Sarah Carr’s book, Hope Against Hope.

Algiers Charter proves that you can motivate through development and validation as opposed to deletion. Schools don’t need the stereotypical stoic business leader who applies scorched-earth policy, but they must be able to motivate the team to achieve. Morgan said, “Algiers Charter is extremely proud of all that we have accomplished during our first ten years, but success in the next decade requires all “A” and “B” schools. That’s the championship I want to win. Our students deserve nothing less.”

Go Algiers Charter! Build momentum for the upcoming year by validating the people who need change.

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news website focused on inequality and innovation in education. Read more columns by Andre Perry.

*Corrects to reflect that the name of the school is still officially Algiers Charter School Association

The Hechinger Report provides in-depth, fact-based, unbiased reporting on education that is free to all readers. But that doesn't mean it's free to produce. Our work keeps educators and the public informed about pressing issues at schools and on campuses throughout the country. We tell the whole story, even when the details are inconvenient. Help us keep doing that.

Join us today.

Letters

Andre Perry

Dr. Andre Perry, a contributing writer, is a David M. Rubenstein Fellow at The Brookings Institution. Perry was the founding dean of urban education at… See Archive

Letters to the Editor

Send us your thoughts

At The Hechinger Report, we publish thoughtful letters from readers that contribute to the ongoing discussion about the education topics we cover. Please read our guidelines for more information.

By submitting your name, you grant us permission to publish it with your letter. We will never publish your email. You must fill out all fields to submit a letter.





No letters have been published at this time.