The Hechinger Report covers one topic: education. Sign up for our newsletters to have stories delivered to your inbox. Consider becoming a member to support our nonprofit journalism.

Website for Mind/Shift
This story also appeared in Mind/Shift

For years, higher education policy has focused on getting more Americans into college and helping more of them graduate. Now the emphasis has shifted to another question: What are students and the general public getting out of these degrees?

Colleges are being pressed to show that their graduates find good jobs and earn enough to justify the cost of their education. And as criticism of higher education mounts, colleges face additional pressure to show that they are fueling their regional economies.

State policymakers are responding. Both red and blue states are stepping up their efforts to identify which fields are most needed for producing future workers and using those lists to steer subsidies to academic programs — everything from short-term training to graduate school. 

A new 50-state report released today by HCM Strategists, a firm that advises on and advocates for higher education policies, documents how states are identifying high-priority fields of study. It’s something of a central planning exercise, trying to predict what will be needed in the future. Some states rely on labor-market data, including wages and projections of occupational growth. Others use human judgment and advice from employers and industry experts. Still others combine the two.

The stakes are high. Roughly half the states incorporate their priority lists into funding formulas, giving colleges additional money for producing degrees in designated fields. Thirty-five states help pay for the costs of starting up a new degree program in high-priority fields. 

Nearly every state has a student financial aid program tied to its high-priority fields, too, according to HCM. For example, Virginia has a program that eliminates community college tuition and fees for students who pursue majors it deems in high demand, such as computer science. Some states forgive student loans in desirable fields. Collectively, these incentives can increase the size of some academic departments while leaving others with fewer resources. 

All 50 states have some method for designating high-priority fields. Many work backwards. They start by identifying occupations they consider valuable, based on wages or projections of job growth. Then they connect those occupations to college fields of study. If computer programmers are in demand and earn good salaries, for example, computer science programs may be designated as high priority. But that doesn’t mean the state knows whether computer science graduates are actually getting those jobs, or whether those jobs are being filled by people who studied something else.

One obstacle to measuring graduates’ actual outcomes is the limitation of state unemployment insurance records. These databases track workers’ earnings but often don’t identify their precise occupations. A worker in the healthcare industry, for example, could be an accountant, a doctor, a marketer or a cafeteria cook. The state might know that the person works in healthcare and how much they earn, but not what they do.

“When states are trying to set eligibility for financial aid programs, trying to figure out which programs should receive weights in their funding formulas, they are, more often than not, using that proxy alignment, and not looking at students’ actual outcomes,” said Tom Allison, director of state policy and finance at HCM Strategists and one of the report’s authors.

Ten states have upgraded their wage records to include more detailed occupational information. Only seven states use actual employment outcomes for graduates of specific college programs when deciding which fields to prioritize. Three states — Arkansas, Texas and Ohio — go a step further, considering both what students pay for college and what they earn afterward.

Arkansas, for example, compares post-secondary graduates’ cumulative earnings with their educational costs and contrasts that against what high school graduates earn. Then, Arkansas gives a bigger funding boost to programs whose graduates reach a positive return on investment sooner.

Allison says states are improving their data systems, in part to comply with new federal regulations, such as those governing the new federal Pell grants that pay for shorter workforce training programs. Those upgrades ought to improve how states go about identifying high-priority fields throughout higher education. 

However, all of these calculations are based on the past. As artificial intelligence, automation and globalization reshape labor markets, states are trying to predict which jobs will be valuable years from now.

Tennessee, for example, is trying to establish itself as a leader in nuclear energy, an industry that doesn’t yet rank highly in the state’s historical employment data. New plants could create thousands of jobs, from welders and electricians to nuclear engineers. Tennessee is among nine states that allow local employers or other members of the public to petition the state to add fields that its data-driven formula might otherwise overlook.

More than half of states, 38, include fields they consider essential to public services or providing “societal value” even if they don’t pay off in the labor market. Connecticut, for example, has designated nursing and social work as priority fields, regardless of what its general methodology might indicate. Oregon has similarly elevated training for teachers of English-language learners to address an acute shortage. 

“We see a lot of states trying to balance jobs that may not pay very well, but they know are strategic for the state,” said Allison.

States also face an updating dilemma. If they update their priority lists too frequently, colleges may struggle to plan programs and hire faculty around shifting priorities. But if they wait too long, the lists can become obsolete. Texas, for example, allows a field to fall short of its criteria in two consecutive biennial reviews before removing it from the state’s priority lists.

Government promotion of college academic fields isn’t new. You could go all the way back to the Morrill Acts of 1862 and 1890 that created the land-grant institutions, with the federal government using its resources to promote agricultural and mechanical expertise. But in the last few years, this effort to pick academic winners has gained steam. During the year HCM analysts spent collecting data on state priorities, they had to update it in real time as states passed new policies. Tennessee, for example, updated its methodology for its Workforce Investment Premium this past summer. 

As I was reporting this story, I kept thinking about my years in Moscow, where I began my journalism career. In the 1990s, the new Russian government was trying to dismantle central planning and let market forces determine what the economy needed. Now American states, both red and blue, are using public money to steer students and colleges toward the fields they believe their economies will need. It’s not the same kind of central planning, of course. But it is a remarkable flip-flop on who should make these decisions. I’ll be watching to see how it works out.

Contact staff writer Jill Barshay at 212-678-3595, jillbarshay.35 on Signal, or barshay@hechingerreport.org.

This story about state priorities in higher education was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization that covers education. Sign up for Proof Points and other Hechinger newsletters.

Was this story helpful? Leave a tip to support your education reporters.

The Hechinger Report is a nonprofit newsroom powered by reader support

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.