Divided We Learn

How one university is luring coveted honors students with social justice

To revitalize its home city, Rutgers University-Newark has started an honors program that looks beyond test scores to students' commitment to social change

Rutgers Newark sophomore Stacy Tyndall, 19, laughs at an "Orange Is the New Black"-themed wall of dormitory rules in her campus residence hall. Tyndall, a criminal justice major who wants to be a judge, grew up 15 minutes from the campus.

Rutgers Newark sophomore Stacy Tyndall, 19, laughs at an “Orange Is the New Black”-themed wall of dormitory rules in her campus residence hall. Tyndall, a criminal justice major who wants to be a judge, grew up 15 minutes from the campus.

NEWARK, N.J. — Stacy Tyndall is exactly the kind of person the city of Newark hopes will stick around. She’s smart, ambitious and involved in the community.

But the high-poverty city near New York probably would have lost her to another part of the country were it not for an innovative two-year-old honors program on Rutgers University’s Newark campus. Tyndall turned down a bevy of offers from colleges in other states to attend Rutgers’ Honors Living-Learning Community (HLLC), which brings together dozens of students each year for a residential program that combines rigorous academics with a social-justice focus.

“I applied to a lot of schools — over 20, I think — and I got into every single one,” said Tyndall, with a hint of sheepishness. The 19-year-old sophomore was sitting in her sparsely decorated dormitory suite overlooking downtown Newark, which is about a 15-minute drive from where she grew up. At Rutgers, Tyndall is studying criminal justice and said she plans to be “an old and gray judge.”

“If the HLLC wasn’t here,” she said, “there’s no way I would have gone here.”

The HLLC is one of two on-campus programs offering ambitious students from the Newark area a reason to stay close to home. The other program, the Honors College, has existed for decades; in 2016 it retooled its admissions strategy to attract students with a wider range of academic interests. Both programs are expanding as public universities nationwide start — or tweak — honors curricula to compete with selective private colleges for top students.

Among Rutgers’ goals is boosting the educational fortunes of a city that has some of the lowest rates of college attainment nationwide. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, fewer than 14 percent of Newark residents 25 or older have a bachelor’s degree — less than half the national average. And just 4 percent of city residents hold a graduate degree, compared to 12 percent nationally.

That lack of attainment is perhaps not surprising: Until last year, Newark’s public schools had been under state control since 1995, when a state investigation revealed school environments that “virtually assure academic failure.” In September, after Newark students showed academic gains, New Jersey education officials voted to return control of the city’s public schools to the local school board, 22 years after the state Board of Education took over the tattered district.

Rutgers leaders hope that by offering competitive honors programs for students with a passion for equality and justice, they can attract more of the public schools’ top performers and encourage them to stay put to help combat the city’s problems. Both HLLC and Honors College leaders say they’ve been impressed by the academic abilities and social consciousness of local applicants.

Overall, the campus has attracted nearly 60 percent more students from Newark since 2013, the result of a concerted effort by Rutgers and other local groups to boost college-going rates in the city, university officials said.

“We definitely want Newark students to feel like this is a place where they can come and succeed,” said Nancy Cantor, chancellor of Rutgers-Newark, which is playing a key role in the local drive to boost the share of city residents who hold college degrees and other post-secondary credentials from 12.2 percent in 2000 to 25 percent by 2025.

Related: What happens when a college recruits black students others consider too risky?

College honors programs, which typically give top academic performers access to a supplemental curriculum and other benefits, have been around for almost a century, but their numbers have grown dramatically since the 1990s, according to the National Collegiate Honors Council. While the Newark Honors College still hews to a relatively traditional approach, the Living-Learning Community is redefining from scratch what it means to be an honors student.

HLLC admissions officers look beyond grades and SAT scores to students’ leadership qualities and their interest in the world around them. This is assessed first through group interviews where students are judged on how they collaborate with other students; the top 60 percent are then invited back for a one-on-one interview. Successful applicants have developed ideas for alleviating social problems and have volunteered in their communities, Rutgers officials say.

The HLLC students, who number roughly 160, come from varied backgrounds. They range in age from their teens to their late 40s; some have served time in prison, and many balance their studies with family obligations. Roughly half are African-American or Latino, and about two-thirds are from the greater Newark area. “We really are sensitive to the need to stop overlooking students from Newark,” said Timothy Eatman, dean of the Living-Learning Community.

Once admitted, students receive a scholarship that covers their housing and meals. Residing on campus with their peers is obligatory. For now, students live in a handful of dorms across campus, but a new building to be opened next year will consolidate living spaces and classrooms in one location. The new HLLC facility — financed through bonds and by a developer who plans to add stores and restaurants to the building — will also include a handful of suites for students with families, according to Engelbert Santana, the program’s assistant dean of advisement. After the building’s completion, the HLLC will be able to expand to at least 400 students.

“It makes a difference if they’re here,” said Santana, sitting in his temporary office in a former dormitory suite, complete with a leaky shower. “Rather than commuting back and forth from home, they can use those 30 minutes in the library. Students do better when they’re together and can study at their own pace, without the distractions at home.”

Living-Learning students participate in what amounts to an intensive, interdisciplinary minor. All of the program’s courses revolve around a central theme: local citizenship in a global world. Classes, which combine liberal arts and a focus on careers, might examine topics such as Newark’s history or residential racial segregation, or teach students about marketing for nonprofit organizations. Students must complete a final research or service project on social inequity in a local community — preferably Newark.

Rutgers Newark freshman Saied Beckford, an 18-year-old freshman, points out downtown Newark landmarks from his seventh-floor suite in a campus residence hall.

Rutgers Newark freshman Saied Beckford, an 18-year-old freshman, points out downtown Newark landmarks from his seventh-floor suite in a campus residence hall.

Saied Beckford, an 18-year-old majoring in economics and computer science, lives on the seventh floor of a residence hall that houses many HLLC students. After moving with his mother from Jamaica three years ago, he graduated from a 1,600-student public high school in nearby East Orange.

Like other Living-Learning students, Beckford plans to spend his career fighting for social justice. He uses the argot of advocates and do-gooders, calling himself an aspiring “change agent,” a term mentioned frequently by HLLC leaders and students. Eventually, he’d like to serve as either the U.S. Treasury secretary or chairman of the Federal Reserve, and influence economic policy from within the system.

Beckford, dressed in a T-shirt bearing the name of the Living-Learning program, said he’s looking forward to living with all his classmates in the new building. “We’ll have more great minds thinking in one place,” he said. “Great things are bound to happen.”

Related: These colleges turn low-income students into middle-class earners — but how?

At the nearby Honors College, a different flock of students is also trying to boost the Newark campus’s prominence.

Miriam Ibrahim’s parents told her she could apply to any college she liked, as long as it was within commuting distance of their home in Livingston, New Jersey. In exchange, they promised to help her pay for grad school anywhere she wanted. Ibrahim, a Coptic Orthodox, was impressed by Rutgers’ financial aid offers and its vibrant Coptic Orthodox community: She chose the Honors College.

Although the college has existed for decades — it first graduated students in 1973 — its new leader is trying to ensure that Honors College students like Ibrahim are part of Newark’s revival.

A 20-year-old sophomore, Ibrahim has volunteered at Newark-area soup kitchens and community gardens as she works toward a bachelor’s degree in economics and pre-med. “Newark is a very interesting area,” she said. “The Honors College helps you look at who’s around you. It’s nice to have all these opportunities around you to help people.”

The college admits students based on their academics, extracurriculars and essays. Most applicants must achieve a grade-point average of 3.5 or higher to qualify, but exceptions are sometimes made for students who show promise. Honors College admission previously was tied directly to a Rutgers scholarship based on standardized test scores, but the program tweaked the process to allow a broader range of students to apply.

“What we’re trying to find are people who are curious and interested in taking control of their education,” said Brian Murphy, who started as the Honors College director in 2016.

Honors College students participate in seminars and service projects and take a freshman colloquium. Recent topics have included science and religion, theater, performance and culture, and the “role of the media in transforming behavior.”

The Honors College enrolls a smaller proportion of African-American and Latino students than the rest of the campus, and just 16 percent of its students are from Newark, Murphy said. But, like HLCC, the Honors College is trying to step up its efforts to recruit applicants from nearby high schools. “As I tell my kids, our students are so marketable when they come out of this program,” Michael West, a vice principal at Newark’s East Side High School, said of the Honors College. “They’re in a great position in the job market.”

Related story: The community college “segregation machine”

As a major research university with top faculty and a vast array of classes, Rutgers is an exciting place to be for Honors College and HLLC students alike, said Murphy, a former journalist. “Rutgers Newark has a good story to tell,” he said. “To have all of that at the same time? I just don’t know who else has that and is public.”

The nascent HLLC program is attracting interest from other campuses. One of its deans, for example, is scheduled to discuss the program as a “model for creating inclusive campus communities” at a national convention of student affairs administrators in March.

Although the university is examining HLLC data to see how its admissions policies are working, Santana said early returns are promising. HLLC students earned, on average, a 3.2 GPA he said, and all are performing at least as well academically as their non-HLLC Rutgers peers.

“We’ve had numerous conversations with numerous schools about this program,” he said. “We’re trying to build a national model.”

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. Sign up for our newsletter.

Letters

Matt Krupnick

Matt Krupnick is a freelance reporter and editor who contributes regularly to The New York Times and the Hechinger Report. He was a reporter with… See Archive

Letters to the Editor

Send us your thoughts

At The Hechinger Report, we publish thoughtful letters from readers that contribute to the ongoing discussion about the education topics we cover. Please read our guidelines for more information.

By submitting your name, you grant us permission to publish it with your letter. We will never publish your email. You must fill out all fields to submit a letter.





No letters have been published at this time.